Jasmine Cottage, Birchover

Jasmine Cottage is a cosy stone cottage in a properly dog-friendly corner of the Peak District. Birchover is a small, quiet village with two pubs, and dog owners consistently describe the Druid Inn as welcoming to dogs and worth eating at, with a dog-friendly bakery for breakfast in nearby Youlgreave. It earns a 4.3/5 paw rating from guests who have stayed with their dogs.

The strongest part of the experience is the setting. Guests talk about morning walks around the village, passing alpacas and peacocks, with footpaths in every direction and Bakewell and Chatsworth close by. Inside, the cottage is described as homely and traditional, with plenty of room for a group to sit around the big table, comfortable reclining chairs and sofas, and a smart TV. Parking is easy, and the host is generally quick to reply.

The caveats are significant, though, and dog owners raise them more than other guests do. There is no garden, and access to the back of the property is not available, so outdoor space is limited to a shared driveway; every outing means a lead and a walk. Cleanliness is the most frequent complaint, with reports of dusty surfaces, cobwebs, stained bedding and basics such as washing-up liquid, tea or milk missing. Some guests have found towels and beds disappointing too. The cottage sits in the village rather than overlooking open fields, and there is another property with the same name about 20 minutes away, so use the exact address and coordinates when you set off. The property's booking listing does not set out a pet fee or a limit on dogs, so confirm the details directly.

For walkers who plan to spend their days on the trails and their evenings in a dog-friendly village pub, Jasmine Cottage puts you in a great spot. Those who need a garden for their dog, or who are particular about housekeeping, may be happier elsewhere.